Open Access Research

Non-identical smoothing operators for estimating time-frequency interdependence in electrophysiological recordings

Saeid Mehrkanoon12*, Michael Breakspear123, Andreas Daffertshofer4 and Tjeerd W Boonstra124

Author Affiliations

1 School of Psychiatry, The University of New South Wales

2 Black Dog Institute, Hospital Rd, Randwick, NSW 2031, Australia

3 Queensland Institute of Medical Research, Brisbane, Australia

4 Research Institute MOVE, VU University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands

For all author emails, please log on.

EURASIP Journal on Advances in Signal Processing 2013, 2013:73  doi:10.1186/1687-6180-2013-73

Published: 10 April 2013

Abstract

Synchronization of neural activity from distant parts of the brain is crucial for the coordination of cognitive activities. Because neural synchronization varies both in time and frequency, time–frequency (T-F) coherence is commonly employed to assess interdependences in electrophysiological recordings. T-F coherence entails smoothing the cross and power spectra to ensure statistical consistency of the estimate, which reduces its T-F resolution. This trade-off has been described in detail when the cross and power spectra are smoothed using identical smoothing operators, which may yield spurious coherent frequencies. In this article, we examine the use of non-identical smoothing operators for the estimation of T-F interdependence, i.e., phase synchronization is characterized by phase locking between signals captured by the cross spectrum and we may hence improve the trade-off by selectively smoothing the auto spectra. We first show that the frequency marginal density of the present estimate is bound within [0,1] when using non-identical smoothing operators. An analytic calculation of the bias and variance of present estimators is performed and compared with the bias and variance of standard T-F coherence using Monte Carlo simulations. We then test the use of non-identical smoothing operators on simulated data, whose T-F properties are known through construction. Finally, we analyze empirical data from eyes-closed surface electroencephalography recorded in human subjects to investigate alpha-band synchronization. These analyses show that selectively smoothing the auto spectra reduces the bias of the estimator and may improve the detection of T-F interdependence in electrophysiological data at high temporal resolution.

Keywords:
Coherence; Time–frequency analysis; Electroencephalography; Functional connectivity; Neural synchronization